A couple of weeks ago, during my not-so-great
TV Week Project, I watched a couple of superhero movies back-to-back. Unless you've been in a coma for the last three years you've heard of them:
The Incredibles and
Spider-Man 2. There's really no point in reviewing them. If you like superheros you will love them, if not, you probably won't. The Incredibles is a loving parody of the genre; a CGI animated feature. Spider-Man 2, of course, brings the classic comic book characters and story to life, with CGI animated action scenes. Seeing the two 2004 movies in two days gave me an unexpected perspective on the genre.
Mr. Incredible is forcibly retired from active superhero-ing because of lawyers, insurance, and governmental idiocy (the same forces that threaten to destroy everything good about our culture, but that's another rant . . .). He is trying to fit in as a white-collar cubicle-cramped suburban family man. And he hates it. He yearns for the old days, when he could slip on the cool costume, show off his remarkable abilities, and do good.
In Spider-Man 2 Peter Parker chooses to retire from being a hero so that he can focus on being a normal guy. Being a hero is a burden he would be rid of, a responsibility that he takes no joy in.
Of course both heroes eventually do as expected. Mr. I. jumps at the chance to fight the good fight again. His whole super-family gets in on the act and the rest of the movie is exciting, hilarious, and occasionally heart-warming. I loved watching the Incredible family do their thing, and they clearly (especially dad) had fun doing it.
Spider-Man on the other hand . . . there was just no joy in spidey-land. He went back to work because he had to. Peter is driven by morality and a sense of duty. With the exception of one or two "yah-hoos" I can't say that I saw a lot of joy.
Some would say that Spider-Man is the more adult film. I don't think so. I think it is more of an adolescent film. Peter is suffering teen angst and personal confusion. Yes, he makes the grown-up decision, but would it be so hard for an emotionally mature person? I don't think so.
Here's a question then -- if you suddenly developed super powers that allowed you to do great good, wouldn't you? Oh, sure, you'd have some pure, self-indulgent fun, but you'd also rescue people, fight evil, and make the world a better place. And you'd enjoy it right?
Or am I being too optimistic about humanity?